by Rahul Chimanbhai Mehta Rrg at November 27, 2014 at 08:09AM

Please COMPARE tax-laws and DO NOT fall for paid and useless intellectuals who go around saying that "such and such tax is bad" , "such as such tax is bad" and then will support much worse tax laws !! . eg consider SoMoKe , SoMoKe-andbhagats and CoBhApSwaRa-workers. They will yell loudly that wealth tax is bad, income tax is bad and then they will all support 10 times much worse tax such as GST , inheritance tax (which says no inheritance tax on foreigners who invest via trusts and tax will fall only on Indians) etc etc. . We need taxes to bear expenses of Military, buying weapons, police, courts and many thing needed to support above three. eg we we need science and maths education to make weapons and so we need a system to force / motivate students to learn science and maths. Left on their own interest, almost all students will prefer easy subjects like music , painting, etc and if all students are allowed to do what they like, then in 30 years, we wont have any scientists and engineers to make weapons, and then India would slave of USA or China. So maths \ science education is must and since it is uphill task, it needs force and rewards and this needs money. And obviously money will come from taxes. So we need taxes to subsidize maths \ science education. . So ONLY question we have is which tax law is less "bad" . ie. given 10 types of tax laws, such as (a) inheritance tax (b) wealth tax (c) wealth tax minus income tax minus salaries paid (d) income tax (e) GST (f) vat , service tax (g) bank transaction tax (h) stamp duty etc etc, which tax law is LEAST "BAD". And this is inherently subjective question. . The issue we need to analyse is (a) which tax law is regressive in which range (b) which tax law which cause more harassment and which tax law will cause less harassment (c) which tax law is easier to evade and which one is difficult to evade and so forth (d) which tax law UN-NATURALLY favors small over large OR large over small. (e) which tax law benefits foreigners more or less . There is nothing wrong in "ethical" rich , which is again a subjective concept. So tax law needed not be against rich, and a tax law which is anti-rich is not necessarily a good law. Likewise, a tax law which favors foreigners over locals is bad tax law. And also, IMO, a tax law which taxes foreigners far more than locals isnt necessarily a good tax law. . All in all, we MUST compare tax laws. . 1. SoMoKe , SoMoKe-andbhagats and CoBhApSwaRa-workers DO NOT want voters to get into understanding of political, social , economic implications of tax laws !! SoMoKe , SoMoKe-andbhagats and CoBhApSwaRa-workers want activist to stay busy with brooming , uploading selfies etc etc . 2. However, when some activists like recallists initiate debate on taxes, then SoMoKe , SoMoKe-andbhagats and CoBhApSwaRa workers loudly oppose wealth tax saying "taxes are bad, taxes are bad" . 3. Same SoMoKe , SoMoKe-andbhagats and CoBhApSwaRa workers loudly support VAT / Service tax and now GST , which will kill small businesses and favor large due to "missing trader clause". . 4. And lastly, SoMoKe , SoMoKe-andbhagats and CoBhApSwaRa-workers have started campaigning for inheritance tax which will tax only wealth of Indian riches and will NOT tax wealth owned by foreigners in India !!! . So we recallists have 3 tasks. . A) We need to inform activists and voters about various tax laws and implications. . B) Each activist need to decide which tax laws he supports and ask voters and activists to send order to MP via SMS containing URL \ URN to the tax law he supports . C) inform all voters and activists that SoMoKe , SoMoKe-andbhagats and CoBhApSwaRa-workers support tax laws which damage small businesses and which benefit foreigners at the cost of India. . We should do above 3 tasks, using pamphlets , newspaper advt and FB posts.

by Rahul Chimanbhai Mehta Rrg



from Right to Recall Group http://ift.tt/1HHdt5F

via Bhavik Barai